Back to blog
RFP & Brand

Capability Gets You Considered. Fit Gets You Shortlisted.

Nancy Campbell | Founder, 10Marketing Consulting

By the time a consultant and buying group sit down to score RFP responses, most of the providers in the running can do the work. Some do it better than others, and those differences matter. But in my experience, capability alone rarely decides who makes the shortlist.

What tends to make the difference is fit. By fit, I mean the buying group's sense, as they read your response, that you are the right long-term partner for them. You are the organization they'll trust through the ups and downs that come with running a complex benefits plan, retirement plan, or HR function.

Every response describes capability. The ones that also show fit are the ones buying groups remember.

Fit is a feeling. Brand is how you show it.

Fit isn't something you can simply claim. Writing "we are the right partner for you" rarely persuades a careful buying group. Fit comes through in how you respond: your tone, how you organize your answers, and the care you put into each one.

This is where your brand comes in. I don't mean your logo or your colours. I mean your purpose, vision, and values, and the experience clients have with you. It's how those show up in the way you sell, the way your people talk about their work, and the way you take part in your community. When that comes through in a response, the buying group gets a real sense of who you are.

Recent research from Bain & Company and LinkedIn supports this. In a survey of 750 B2B buyers, including buyers of HR technology, Bain identified five themes that shape buying decisions. One is whether a vendor feels like a "safe" choice the buyer can defend inside their own organization.[1] To me, that is a good description of fit.

Impressions form before the RFP arrives

It's also worth remembering that your buying group has likely started to form a view of you well before your RFP response reaches them. Two pieces of research help explain why.

The first is what Bain calls the "Day 1 list." These are the vendors a buyer already has in mind when the buying process begins. Bain cites research showing that about 90% of buyers purchase from that list. Its own analysis with LinkedIn found that brand reputation, trust, and perceived risk often carry more weight than product features.[1]

The second is how buyers now do their early research. Forrester reports that generative AI search is now the starting point for B2B buyers. As I wrote in Part 1 of this series, that means many buyers open your response with an impression of you already in mind.

So I find it helpful to think about an RFP response a little differently. It usually isn't a first impression. It's your chance to confirm, or gently reshape, the impression a buyer already has.

Where fit comes from

Showing fit in your responses comes from two things working together:

  • Your brand, shown authentically. Your purpose, vision, and values are easy to see.
  • Clear evidence that you understand this client. Their goals, the pressures they face, and how they like to make decisions.

One without the other falls short. A strong brand with no sign that you understand the client can read as generic. Deep client insight with no sense of who you are can read as capable but forgettable. Together, they show the buying group what working with you would feel like.

Fit belongs in every part of your response

It's tempting to put fit on the introduction page and move on. But fit needs to carry through the whole response. That includes your company story, how you position each division or function, each product or service description, and the features you choose to highlight.

Fit also shows up in how you write. If you describe your firm as client-centred, it helps when the writing is client-centred too. That means leading with the client's needs and using plain language. Forrester reports that a typical B2B buying decision now involves 13 internal stakeholders, plus nine external influencers.[2] Many of them won't be benefits, pension, or HR specialists. Clear writing helps each of them see why you could be a good fit.

A good place to start

If your responses tend to get good feedback on capability, but the close calls don't go your way, it may be worth looking at how fit comes through. One simple question I like to ask is this: can the prospective client see both what you can do and who you are?

That question is one part of the Hurdle1 RFP Success diagnostic. Part 1 of this series focused on understanding your buyer. This piece focuses on the response itself, and whether your differentiation and your fit with the client shine through from the first page to the last. If you'd like to learn more, you'll find details at hurdle1rfp.ca.

Nancy Campbell | Founder, 10Marketing Consulting | 10marketingconsulting.com

References

  1. [1]Bain & Company (R. Dave, Z. Prauer, I. Carikcioglu, M. Whitley, E. Nazander, J. Cleghorn), "Raising the Odds on a Deal: How Likelihood to Buy Rewires B2B Growth," June 19, 2026. Based on a Bain and LinkedIn survey of 750 B2B buyers, conducted with NewtonX in February 2026. https://www.bain.com/insights/raising-the-odds-on-a-deal-how-likelihood-to-buy-rewires-b2b-growth/
  2. [2]Forrester, "Forrester's 2026 Buyer Insights: GenAI Is Upending B2B Buying As Leaders Face Mounting Pressure To Justify Every Dollar Spent," press release on The State Of Business Buying, 2026, January 21, 2026. https://www.forrester.com/press-newsroom/forrester-2026-the-state-of-business-buying/

Want to strengthen your RFP responses?

Hurdle1 RFP Success helps Canadian group benefits, group retirement, and HR organizations win more of the business they compete for.

Learn about Hurdle1 RFP Success